INSULATION COORDINATION FOR TRANSMISSION LINES: COMPLETE TECHNICAL GUIDE (IEC 60071, IEC 60826, IEEE C62)

 

INSULATION COORDINATION FOR TRANSMISSION LINES: COMPLETE TECHNICAL GUIDE (IEC 60071, IEC 60826, IEEE C62)


1. Introduction

Insulation coordination is one of the most critical components of transmission line design. It ensures that line insulation, hardware, insulators, air clearances, towers, and surge protection systems can reliably withstand the electrical stresses imposed by:

  • lightning impulses

  • switching surges

  • temporary overvoltages (TOV)

  • power-frequency overvoltages

  • backflashovers and shielding failures

Poor insulation coordination directly leads to:

  • high line outage rates

  • unnecessary tripping

  • insulator flashover

  • equipment damage

  • reduced reliability indices (SAIDI, SAIFI)

  • unacceptable lightning performance

Modern utilities follow international standards such as:

  • IEC 60071-1 & 60071-2 (main standard for insulation coordination)

  • IEC 60826 (overhead line reliability)

  • IEEE C62 (surge protection)

  • CIGRE Technical Brochures (TB) on lightning performance

  • Utility-specific manuals (e.g., NGCP TLDS, PGES)

This article provides a comprehensive and extremely detailed methodology for conducting insulation coordination for high-voltage transmission lines ranging from 69 kV to 500 kV and beyond.

2. Objectives of Insulation Coordination

Insulation coordination aims to:

✔ Determine insulation levels

Determine the BIL (Basic Insulation Level) and SIL/SWL required for:

  • insulators

  • air clearances

  • tower geometry

  • substation interfaces

✔ Limit the probability of flashover

Maintain a design where the probability of flashover is lower than a target value defined by standards.

✔ Optimize insulation cost

Avoid overdesign (expensive, unnecessary insulation) and underdesign (prone to outages).

✔ Ensure consistency across the system

Transmission lines, substations, transformers, breakers, surge arresters must all share a coordinated insulation scheme.

3. Types of Overvoltages Considered in Insulation Coordination

3.1 Lightning Overvoltages

These are fast-front surges (1.2/50 μs) due to:

  • direct lightning strikes

  • backflashover

  • shielding failures

  • induced overvoltages

Lightning surges require insulation with sufficient BIL.

3.2 Switching Overvoltages

Slow-front surges (250/2500 μs) caused by:

  • line energization

  • line de-energization

  • reclosing

  • fault clearing

  • load rejection

At 345 kV and above, switching surges govern insulation design, not lightning.

3.3 Temporary Overvoltage (TOV)

Power-frequency sustained overvoltages from:

  • unbalanced faults

  • ferroresonance

  • ground faults

  • load rejection issues

TOV influences the withstand capabilities of long air gaps, hardware, and surge arrester duty.

3.4 Power Frequency Overvoltage

Normally occurs during:

  • phase-to-ground faults

  • load rejection

  • improper synchronizing

4. Key Insulation Parameters

4.1 BIL (Basic Insulation Level)

The withstand capability under a lightning impulse.

Typical BIL values:

  • 69 kV → 325 kV BIL

  • 115 kV → 550 kV BIL

  • 230 kV → 1050–1100 kV BIL

  • 500 kV → 1550–1800 kV BIL

4.2 CWW (Chopped Wave Withstand)

Important for switching operations where gas breakers generate chopped-wave stresses.

4.3 SIWL (Switching Impulse Withstand Level)

Governs EHV/UHV (>300 kV) lines.

Typical:

  • 345 kV → ~900 kV SIWL

  • 500 kV → 1050–1200 kV SIWL

4.4 CFO (Critical Flashover Voltage)

Voltage at which insulation flashes over 50% of the time.

CFO directly determines:

  • air clearance

  • tower geometry

  • insulator string length

5. Insulation Coordination Methodology (IEC 60071-2)

STEP 1 — Identify All Overvoltage Stresses

For each voltage class, determine:

  • lightning impulse stresses

  • switching impulse stresses

  • TOV stresses

  • induced overvoltages

  • arrester discharge voltages

Use:

  • EMTP simulations

  • line energization studies

  • fast-front surge modeling

STEP 2 — Determine Insulation Withstand Levels

Use withstand curves from:

  • IEC 60071 tables

  • manufacturer specs

  • CIGRE guides

Insulation types:

  1. External insulation

    • air clearances

    • insulator strings

    • tower hardware

  2. Internal insulation

    • equipment in substations

    • transformer windings

    • breaker gaps

Transmission lines use external insulation coordination almost exclusively.

STEP 3 — Select BIL & SIWL Values

Governed by:

  • shielding angle

  • tower height

  • lightning density (Ng)

  • ground resistivity

  • tower footing resistance

BIL must be:

  • greater than all expected lightning surges

  • compatible with surge arrester protective levels

  • coordinated with adjacent substations

STEP 4 — Determine Air Clearances

Using curves from:

  • IEC 60071-2 (air gap withstand)

  • EPRI / CIGRE

  • Utility standards

Air gap withstand depends on:

  • atmospheric correction factor (Ka)

  • altitude correction factor

  • polarity of impulse

  • gap geometry

Example clearance requirement for 230 kV:

  • phase-to-ground: 2.7–3.5 m

  • phase-to-phase: 3.5–4.5 m

STEP 5 — Shielding Against Lightning

Transmission lines must minimize:

  • backflashover

  • shielding failure flashover

a) Shielding angle

Typical:

  • 230 kV: 20–30°

  • 500 kV: 10–15°

b) Ground wire placement

  • 1 or 2 GW wires

  • sometimes OPGW

c) Tower footing resistance

Target:

  • <10 Ω for 230–500 kV

  • lower in high lightning areas

STEP 6 — Backflashover Analysis

Backflashover occurs when:

  • lightning hits tower or shield wire

  • tower potential rises

  • insulator string flashes over

Calculate tower voltage rise:

V=I⋅R+LdidtV = I \cdot R + L\frac{di}{dt}

Where:

  • I = lightning current

  • R = footing resistance

  • L = tower inductance

Flashover probability determined using:

  • CFO curves

  • EMTP models

  • CIGRE TB 63/195/411 methods

STEP 7 — Surge Arrester Coordination

Surge arresters limit overvoltage magnitude.

Insulation must satisfy:

Withstand Level>Arrester Discharge Voltage×Margin\text{Withstand Level} > \text{Arrester Discharge Voltage} \times \text{Margin}

Typical margin:

  • 15% lightning

  • 25% switching

At 345–500 kV lines, series compensation may require line side surge arresters.

STEP 8 — Switching Surge Evaluation

For EHV/UHV lines, switching surges dominate.

Factors:

  • line length

  • line energization sequence

  • pre-insertion resistors

  • trapped charge

  • reclosing timing

Target switching surge probability:

  • < 2% (IEC limit)

Simulated using EMTP, PSCAD, or ATP.

STEP 9 — Check Temporary Overvoltage (TOV) Performance

TOV must not exceed:

  • insulator power-frequency withstand

  • arrester thermal capability

Sources of TOV:

  • earth faults

  • resonance

  • load rejection

  • ferroresonance

TOV values can reach:

  • 1.4–1.8 pu on unfaulted phases

  • 2.0–2.5 pu in isolated systems

STEP 10 — Final Insulation Coordination Check

Complete check includes:

  • lightning impulse withstand

  • switching impulse withstand

  • TOV withstand

  • arrester coordination

  • clearance compliance

  • shielding performance

  • grounding adequacy

Output documentation includes:

  • insulation selection sheet

  • CFO vs surge margin table

  • shielding failure rate (SFR) calculation

  • backflashover rate (BFR)

  • EMTP simulation results

6. Lightning Performance of Transmission Lines

Utilities target:

  • < 1–3 flashes / 100 km / year on 230 kV

  • < 0.5–1 flash / 100 km / year on 500 kV

Lightning performance depends on:

  • Ng (ground flash density)

  • tower height

  • shielding angle

  • conductor height

  • ground wire position

  • footing resistance

CIGRE provides analytical models:

  • Eriksson model

  • Wagner model

  • Rusck model

  • Transmission line lightning performance model (CIGRE TB 63)

7. Insulation Coordination Example (230 kV Line)

Step-by-step:

  1. Determine lightning & switching surges using EMTP

  2. Select BIL = 1050 kV

  3. Select SIWL = 850 kV

  4. Calculate minimum air clearances

  5. Model shielding with 25° angle

  6. Set tower footing resistance ≤10 Ω

  7. Check backflashover probability

  8. Select arresters with Upl = 650–700 kV

  9. Verify margins:

    BIL>Upl×1.15BIL > Upl \times 1.15

  10. Validate performance using CIGRE SFR/BFR formulas

8. Why Transmission Line Insulation Coordination Must Be Done Professionally

Insulation coordination directly affects:

  • system reliability

  • CAPEX (insulator selection)

  • tower geometry

  • outages and SAIFI/SAIDI

  • compliance with IEC/IEEE/utility standards

Under-designed insulation → outages, failures, safety hazards
Over-designed insulation → excessive cost

9. Summary

This technical guide demonstrated that insulation coordination for transmission lines requires:

  • advanced surge modeling

  • rigorous comparison of withstand vs stress curves

  • coordinated performance of arresters, insulators, towers

  • shielding & grounding optimization

  • compliance with IEC 60071, IEEE, CIGRE

High-voltage and extra-high-voltage lines depend on precise insulation coordination to maintain safe and reliable operation under lightning and switching transient conditions.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

POLYMERIC INSULATON OF POWER CABLES BASICS AND TUTORIALS

This type of cable can be classified as follows: 1. NEC compounds 2. Elastomers 3. Thermoplastics 4. Thermosettings The rubber and rubber-like insulated cables enjoy their popularity owing to moisture resistance, ease of handling, ease of splicing, and extreme flexibility. Elastomers are materials that can be compressed, stretched, or deformed like rubber and yet retain their original shape. The thermoplastics materials soften when they are reheated, whereas thermosetting-type insulation has very little tendency to soften upon reheating after vulcanization. The earlier oil-based natural rubber compounds have been replaced by synthetic materials, which have better electrical and mechanical characteristics. The following synthetic rubber-like compounds are in use today: Ethylene propylene rubber (EPR) , an elastomer compound: EPR is commonly used in power cables, but is also gaining use in telecommunications and other types of cables. EPR possesses good chemical,...
Read more

ENTRY LEVEL and SENIOR ENGINEERING JOBS

Hello there. On this blog, i will try to compress and collect any available engineering jobs out there with emphasis on the entry level. USA JOBS 1 USA JOBS 2 USA JOBS 3 M.E. JOBS 1 M.E. JOBS 2 M.E. JOBS 3 note: I am in no way related to these job hiring poster.
Read more

SURGE ARRESTER ENERGY HANDLING CAPABILITY FOR TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION LINES APPLICATION TUTORIALS

Image
Photo Courtesy of http://www.classiclightningprotection.com/index.html Metal oxide arresters protect the equipment from high voltage surges by absorbing the energy from the surge. Hence, the energy handling capability (or also called "energy absorption capability" or "energy withstand capability") is an important consideration in the design and application of metal oxide arresters. Most manufacturers publish energy capability values of arresters. However, there are no specified tests either in IEEE/ANSI, or IEC standards. Hence, there is confusion in using these important application parameters. Both IEEE and IEC are contemplating writing standardized tests for the arrester energy handling capability. When metal oxide arresters are energized, valve elements of the arrester will absorb energy which results in a temperature increase of the valve elements. Under normal operating conditions (i.e. absence of overvoltage) there is a balance between the heat...
Read more
free counters